Regulations have just been passed to plug the latest legislative gap inadvertently opened up by the Third Parties (Rights Against Insurers) Act 2010. I have previously written about the need to plug earlier gaps, and the resulting delay in the 2010 Act coming into effect (here, and here).
One of the problems with the Third Parties (Rights Against Insurers) Act 1930, and one of the reasons for reform, was that where the insured defendant is a company which has been struck off the register, a claimant has to restore it to the register for the purpose of obtaining judgment against it. This is because, without judgment against the insured company on liability and quantum, no claim can be made against the company’s liability insurers under the 1930 Act. For cases to which the 1930 Act still applies, which include many long-tail disease cases, the company must still be restored to the register; but for cases to which the 2010 Act applies, it is no longer necessary to do this.
In removing a procedural hurdle for claimants, the 2010 Act created a problem for liability insurers. Now, under the 2010 Act, a liability insurer may have to pay an indemnity on behalf of an insured company without the claimant having restored that company to the register. And if a company has not been restored to the register, its insurers cannot exercise their right of subrogation – by bringing a claim in the name of the defunct company – to recover from a third party damages they have paid to the claimant.
It is open to the insurers themselves to apply to court to restore the company to the register – but unlike an application by a claimant in a personal injury claim, to which no time limit applies, insurers may apply to restore a company to the register only if it has been dissolved in the previous six years.
The 2018 Regulations address this by amending s 1030(1) of the Companies Act 2006. The effect of the amendment is to allow 2010 Act insurers to apply ‘at any time’ to restore a company to the register in order to bring a subrogated claim in respect of the company’s liability for damages for personal injury.
The regulations were made on 2 November 2018. They come into force later this month.
Alison Padfield QC
- See Post Office v Norwich Union Fire Insurance Society Ltd  2 QB 363, CA; Bradley v Eagle Star Insurance Co Ltd  AC 957, HL. ↑
- See Redman v Zurich Insurance plc  EWHC 1919 (QB),  1 WLR 280. ↑
- See s 1029 of the Companies Act 2006. ↑
- There was a time limit, but this was removed in 1989 following the decision in Bradley v Eagle Star Insurance Co Ltd in the House of Lords: see ss 651 and 653 of the Companies Act 1985, as originally enacted and as amended. ↑
- See s 1030(4) of the Companies Act 2006. ↑
- The 2018 Regulations are made under s 19(8)(a) and (9) of the 2010 Act. ↑
- On the 21st day after the day on which they were made: see reg 1. ↑